Tempering Success Rates
Tempering in ArcheAge Chronicles succeeds about 100%, 60% and 40% of the time over the first three levels, then returns to 100% when tier 2 stones take over near +4 or +5, Ser Medieval reported on Nov 3, 2026. By our sum, +3 takes 5.2 to 9.3 attempts on average and 24% of pieces get there without a failure.
Tempering in ArcheAge Chronicles starts at about a 100% success chance, falls to about 60% and then 40% over the first three levels, and jumps back to 100% when tier 2 stones take over at around +4 or +5: at those odds a piece needs five to nine attempts on average to reach +3, depending on what a failure costs, and only 24% get there without a single failure. The percentages are Ser Medieval's, reported on Nov 3, 2026 after about 70 hours of the Early Access build, for armor, with "the same deal with the weapons". XL Games has published no odds: neither its progression post of Oct 15, 2026 nor Jay's Notes of Nov 11, 2026 gives one (both read Nov 13, 2026).
His words, hedges included: "from levels 1 to three, as far as the tempering goes, for armor, it's going to start out at like 100%, then it's going to go down to like 60% success rate, 40%", on tier 1 stones, "and then it's going to go to the tier 2 stones around level four or five, I think. And at that point, the percent chance to succeed is going to go back up to 100%, and then it's going to start going back down from there."
Next: the 59 items whose Temper stats XL Games corrected, and the stones owed, trait points, the other half of getting stronger or the dungeon a creator farmed for stones.
Five attempts or nine
What nobody has put on record is what a failure does, so here are both readings, worked from the reported 100%, 60% and 40%:
| Step | Chance | Attempts on average, if a failure only uses up the stones | Attempts on average, if a failure also drops one level |
|---|---|---|---|
| +0 to +1 | about 100% | 1.0 | 1.0 |
| +1 to +2 | about 60% | 1.7 | 2.3 |
| +2 to +3 | about 40% | 2.5 | 6.0 |
| +0 to +3 | 5.2 | 9.3 |
How the columns are worked: an attempt that succeeds with chance p takes 1/p tries on average, so 1/1.0 + 1/0.6 + 1/0.4 = 5.2. If a failure costs a level, each failure also sends you back through the step below, which nearly doubles the total: 1 + 2.33 + 6 = 9.3. The chance of going straight from +0 to +3 with no failure at all is 1.0 x 0.6 x 0.4 = 24% in both cases.
We do not know which column is the game's. Ser Medieval hoped back in September that failed tempering would at worst downgrade gear and never destroy it (Progression and Traits); no account we have read since says which it is, and his own percentages are rounded ("like 60%"). Count your own attempts on the first few pieces: if +3 costs you about five attempts over several items, failures are free of a level loss; if it is closer to nine, they are not.
The tiers, and where the odds reset
- Tier 1 stones cover the first levels, with the falling odds above.
- Tier 2 stones start "around level four or five", and the chance returns to about 100% before falling again. So the cheapest moment in each tier is its first step, and the costliest is its last.
- How high it goes. XL Games' own table of corrected items lists stats at +0, +5, +10 and +15, so Temper levels run to at least +15 (Jay's Notes, Nov 11, 2026). The odds past the second tier are not in any account we have read.
- Named stones. The Compensation Chest II that XL Games is sending every player holds "Vivid Weapon Tempering Stones" and "Vivid Armor Tempering Stones", so weapons and armor use separate stones.
Where stones come from
Tempering Stones drop from mobs and bosses and are spent at a blacksmith, the same NPC that repairs gear, Ser Medieval says in the same passage. Repeating a dungeon is slow for experience but works "for materials like the tempering stones". In the demo he recommended the Throne of Hinnon for both the weapon and the armor kind (Oct 20, 2026, an older build). ZZav's crafted trade goods paid random boxes that could hold tier 2 tempering charms, though his held only gold (Which Trade Goods Pay Gold).
Since the maintenance of Nov 11, 2026 the stones' bag weight is "adjusted", XL Games' notes say, without giving the number (patch notes, read Nov 13, 2026).
No protection item
Asked about a protection potion for tempering, the developers told Ser Medieval there is none: "this is actually not the case or at least shouldn't be". He adds that it remains to be seen "when we start getting past plus 10". XL Games has promised no pay-to-win items (Price and Pay to Win), and nothing sold for money touches tempering today, because Early Access has no shop.
Sources
- I Played 80 Hours Of The Full Version - Archeage Chronicles MMO Review & Everything You Need To Know, Ser Medieval, Nov 3, 2026 (video; the success chances, tiers, blacksmith, protection potion)
- How To Unlock And Complete Throne Of Hinnon In Archeage Chronicles | Secret Dungeon In The Demo, Ser Medieval, Oct 20, 2026 (video; farming stones in the demo)
- IMPORTANT LAUNCH INFO Housing, Trading & Progression | ARCHEAGE CHRONICLES RELEASE, ZZav, Nov 3, 2026 (video; tempering charms from trade boxes)
- Jay's Notes: About the Equipment Temper Balance Adjustments, XL Games on Steam, Nov 11, 2026 (Temper levels to +15, the chest's stones, no odds; read Nov 13, 2026)
- How Progression Works in ArcheAge Chronicles, XL Games on Steam, Oct 15, 2026 (no tempering odds; read Nov 13, 2026)
- Temporary Maintenance Completed, XL Games on Steam, Nov 12, 2026 (stone weight; read Nov 13, 2026)
Moments
I Played 80 Hours Of The Full Version - Archeage Chronicles MMO Review & Everything You Need To Know
Ser Medieval
See also
-
Temper Rebalance and CompensationXL Games is correcting wrongly linked Temper data on 59 listed weapons and armor pieces in ArcheAge Chronicles (21 nerfed, 6 adjusted, 32 buffed). Characters with affected gear at +5 or higher on Nov 10, 2026 at 11:30 PM PST get Tempering Stones, and every player gets three Compensation Chest II and a Unique cosmetic, the Apple Hat Box, sent on Nov 20, 2026.
-
Progression and TraitsIn ArcheAge Chronicles you level mostly from quests, discoveries and points of interest; each level gives stat points for six stats (Strength, Agility, Constitution, Intelligence, Talent, Endurance). Trait points come only from Raeven's Coilstones, each guarded by a boss, and every weapon has its own trait tree; Nui Tears raise max HP at Nui Statues, and field bosses and chests give gear.
-
Throne of HinnonThrone of Hinnon was the hidden high-level dungeon of the ArcheAge Chronicles Steam Next Fest demo (Oct 19 to 26, 2026), outside the normal quest path and opened with a key hidden in the world; the demo has ended, and XL Games has not said whether the dungeon returns in Early Access. A creator found the key on a ledge at the Sunken Ruins and the door at the Altar of Seals; inside are four sigils and a Reaper boss.
-
Which Trade Goods Pay GoldIn recorded ArcheAge Chronicles play only the Bluesalt Brotherhood Trade Goods paid gold (17,804 for a wagon). Seven Diamond Shores Herb Boxes cost 7,100 gold and paid 50 Watermelon Seedlings, 142 gold a seedling by our sum, and a crafted lumber box paid 9 Standard Additive.
-
Price and Pay to WinArcheAge Chronicles costs $29.99 in the US (36,000 won in Korea) in Early Access, a one-time buy-to-play purchase with no subscription, XL Games announced on Oct 21, 2026. It promises no paid shop at the start of Early Access and no pay-to-win items, ever.
-
Bluesalt BrotherhoodThe Bluesalt Brotherhood is the trading company you join in ArcheAge Chronicles' main story at Seaglass Harbor. Joining opens its daily mission board (6 missions), Trade Wagons and the horse; 1,500 contribution and a promotion quest open a house plot and founding a guild. It is one of three companies and the only one you can join so far.